Rankings Stuck Despite Building Links?

Linkzo

Linkzo

Elite Member
Jr. VIP
Joined
Jun 20, 2015
Messages
5,360
Reaction score
927
Over years, one thing keeps repeating. Where backlinks keep growing, but rankings barely move. Some pages improve, while others stay stuck or fluctuate.

My first reaction isn't always to build more links. I'd check three things first:
  1. Content: Does the page offer anything better than what's already ranking?
  2. Internal links: Are important pages getting enough relevant internal support?
  3. Link relevance: Are the target sites building contextual links or just chasing DR and traffic?
With GEO and AI search becoming more relevant, recently I'd also check whether the brand has useful, consistent information and credible mentions across the web. More links aren't always the answer. Sometimes, we need to fix what's already there.

What's your first move when a site has decent backlinks but rankings refuse to improve: build more links, improve content, or audit the foundation?
 
Advertise on BHW
Well if your page is ranking in this position, I think one thing you want to do is create secondary articles and interlink to your pillar content. This has been a lifesaving methodology that has worked for years for many people and it's still working. Ranking in the top 100 on Google shows that you are ranking for your intended keyword and that's a positive sign for that target key phrase. It obviously shows that the article is good, right?

It now has to do with the authority of the domain. If the authority of the domain is not superb, then the best way, instead of building links, is to create internal links to that article. Create as many supporting articles as possible to link to the pillar article and this should definitely give you some brownie points
 
i do check what the problem might be first before building more link and i follow the same pocess as yours
 
Linkzo said:
  1. Content: Does the page offer anything better than what's already ranking?
  2. Internal links: Are important pages getting enough relevant internal support?
  3. Link relevance: Are the target sites building contextual links or just chasing DR and traffic?
Click to expand...
It's usually one of these or a combination of two or all. This is especially worse when people primarily focus on links with high DA/DR without paying attention to relevance.
Linkzo said:
With GEO and AI search becoming more relevant, recently I'd also check whether the brand has useful, consistent information and credible mentions across the web. More links aren't always the answer. Sometimes, we need to fix what's already there.
Click to expand...
Something interesting I noticed with Google's AI overview is that Google's AI would know and be aware of a site but choose to not rank it, if you search for the name of the site, or a misspelled domain, Google's AI overview would talk about said site but the site won't be featured on the ranking list. I noticed this myself.
 
I agree with checking the foundation first. Supporting articles and internal links can help but I wouldn’t assume every page stuck in the top 100 just needs more authority. I would compare it with the pages ranking above and find what’s missing.
 
I’d also check whether the backlinks are actually being crawled and indexed, and whether the target pages are getting any value from them.

Sometimes the link count keeps growing, but the ranking signals won't change much. So, comparing the pages ranking above you and checking the quality of the actual linking pages can help identify what’s missing before spending more on links.
 
My priority would be on the content side because i can target multiple topics at the same time
SEO Audit is mandatory in any case
 
I would check the content and internal links first every time.

If the page isn’t clearly better than what’s already ranking, more backlinks usually won’t move it much. Fix what’s already there before throwing more links at it.
 
Linkzo said:
Over years, one thing keeps repeating. Where backlinks keep growing, but rankings barely move. Some pages improve, while others stay stuck or fluctuate.

My first reaction isn't always to build more links. I'd check three things first:
  1. Content: Does the page offer anything better than what's already ranking?
  2. Internal links: Are important pages getting enough relevant internal support?
  3. Link relevance: Are the target sites building contextual links or just chasing DR and traffic?
With GEO and AI search becoming more relevant, recently I'd also check whether the brand has useful, consistent information and credible mentions across the web. More links aren't always the answer. Sometimes, we need to fix what's already there.

What's your first move when a site has decent backlinks but rankings refuse to improve: build more links, improve content, or audit the foundation?
Click to expand...
i would verify whether the links are leading to the correct pages nd providing conttextual information, rather than just enhancing website metrics. i would also check whether the rankings were stagnant on the complete site or just a few URLs, since that could help to pinpoint the actual problem.
 
I would perform a content and technical SEO audit first and then move on to link building.

The page has to be aligned with the search intent of users for backlinks to work properly.

Otherwise, even good backlinks will not do any good.
 
First thing to rule out is whether the links are even counted for that page. Check how many of the linking pages are indexed, then look at the target URL in GSC and see if the Google selected canonical is the one you are building to. Links to a URL Google has canonicalised elsewhere, or to a redirected version, mostly go to waste.

After that, intent. If the top results are all category pages or comparison lists and yours is a blog post, no number of links fixes the format mismatch. And two of your own pages swapping places on the same keyword is usually why some pages fluctuate while others sit still. Fix those before building more
 
Sometimes backlinks are fine, but the page is targeting a keyword that’s too competitive for the current site. Trying some easier related terms could help.
 
I would begin by auditing the content and internal linking of the page before adding any backlinks it is possible that more backlinks will not help in case the page is not relevant to the user is search or does not add value over other similar pages what do you usually do to determine the major bottleneck?
 
Linkzo said:
Over years, one thing keeps repeating. Where backlinks keep growing, but rankings barely move. Some pages improve, while others stay stuck or fluctuate.

My first reaction isn't always to build more links. I'd check three things first:
  1. Content: Does the page offer anything better than what's already ranking?
  2. Internal links: Are important pages getting enough relevant internal support?
  3. Link relevance: Are the target sites building contextual links or just chasing DR and traffic?
With GEO and AI search becoming more relevant, recently I'd also check whether the brand has useful, consistent information and credible mentions across the web. More links aren't always the answer. Sometimes, we need to fix what's already there.

What's your first move when a site has decent backlinks but rankings refuse to improve: build more links, improve content, or audit the foundation?
Click to expand...

I’d start with a competitor analysis and technical audit before deciding whether to build more links or improve the content. I’d check what’s changed in the SERPs, which pages and keywords competitors are winning, and whether our pages have any content gaps or internal linking issues.

If the foundation is solid, then I’d evaluate the backlink profile, focusing on relevance and contextual value rather than DR alone. More links won't necessarily solve a ranking problem if we're missing the right content or search intent.

The key is identifying the actual bottleneck before investing more in link building.
 
If your pages are ranking on 11 to 20 position so small changes in the title and content should help but if its stuck on 50 above numbers so the content isnt matching what people are searching for and of course it would help if you can make a pillar article and then link to this other similar topic article to the pillar article this is really effective strategy
 
I would also check whether the page is targeting the right keywords sometimes a small change in keyword focus can help attract more relevant traffic.
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top