DR vs Organic Traffic: Which Matters More When Choosing Backlinks?

GSERP said:
agree, i gonna be add one thing here as look how natural the referring site fits into iits niche and those links make sense in context of pages. metric useful for filtering but overall the quality of placement matter more.
Click to expand...
Absolutely agree with that. Relevance and natural environment are important things first of all.

The metrics may play a filtering role, but still there is nothing like a relevant link which fits perfectly on your website better than the one with high metrics and unnatural environment.
DevArchitect said:
Organic traffic wins every single time. DR/DA metrics can be easily manipulated with Google redirect loops or expired domain 301s. A site with DR 30 that pulls 10k real monthly organic visits from search engines is 100x more valuable than a DR 70 farm that gets zero real traffic. Always check the Ahrefs/Semrush traffic graph for steady organic keywords before buying.
Click to expand...
Absolutely agree. Traffic and relevance matter more than the DR and DA score.

I would look at the metrics and then check for traffic, quality of keywords, relevance of the topic, and the placement of the link.
 
Advertise on BHW
I think authority loss only becomes a real problem when it changes your position against the competition. You can lose backlinks and see your DR drop without losing rankings if you're still strong enough for the SERP. I'd worry less about the number in Ahrefs and more about whether competitors are starting to close the gap.
 
SEO Sparton said:
In analyzing the qualities of the backlink, I consider all the signals together, such as relevancy of topic, organic traffic and its growth, ranking keywords, quality of the referring domain, backlink profile, indexation, quality of content, relevancy of page and placement of the link.

For instance, I would prefer a medium-DR website with stable relevant organic visibility and clean profile over a high-DR website with authority that is not related to my niche.
Click to expand...
Yes, 100% agree! Organic traffic is a major factor these days...
 
When selecting a website for a backlink, I look beyond dr and consider the sites niche relevance, previous backlink history, organic traffic and its trend, content quality, and outbound link profile. Looking at these signals together gives a much clearer picture of the sites actual quality.
 
I look at the actual ranking pages. If the referring page ranks for relevant terms, has stable organic visibility I prefer that over a high DR site whose traffic comes from unrelated keywords.
 
I look at the same things too, but I pay a lot of attention to the traffic and the page where the link will be placed. A site with steady traffic, relevant content, and a clean backlink profile can be a really useful link even if the DR isn’t very high.
 
I’d look at the overall quality rather than DR alone. Relevant organic traffic, topical relevance, a clean backlink profile and good indexing usually matter more to me. A medium DR site with real, relevant traffic can be more useful than a high-DR site with no relevant visibility.
 
Sarah Mathews said:
When selecting a website for a backlink, I look beyond dr and consider the sites niche relevance, previous backlink history, organic traffic and its trend, content quality, and outbound link profile. Looking at these signals together gives a much clearer picture of the sites actual quality.
Click to expand...
That’s right. DR is just one indicator. You might want to consider other factors such as relevance, traffic trends, backlinks, and outgoing links at the same time.
KoD- said:
I look at the actual ranking pages. If the referring page ranks for relevant terms, has stable organic visibility I prefer that over a high DR site whose traffic comes from unrelated keywords.
Click to expand...
Agreed. The actual linking page matters more than DR alone.

If it has relevant rankings, stable organic traffic, and strong topical relevance, it can be a much more valuable placement.
 
Ahrefs organic traffic isn't measured, it's estimated. Keywords the site ranks for, multiplied by search volume, run through a click curve. So a site ranking well for a handful of fat irrelevant terms prints a large traffic figure while sending nobody within a mile of your niche. HustleTong's right that it's harder to fake than DR, but it's still inferred rather than observed. Read the keyword list, not the total.
 
I think DR is not much important, because its a third party metrices. For backlinks, Organic traffic and relevancy of your niche is the most important things.
 
zeebone said:
Ahrefs organic traffic isn't measured, it's estimated. Keywords the site ranks for, multiplied by search volume, run through a click curve. So a site ranking well for a handful of fat irrelevant terms prints a large traffic figure while sending nobody within a mile of your niche. HustleTong's right that it's harder to fake than DR, but it's still inferred rather than observed. Read the keyword list, not the total.
Click to expand...
Right. Ahrefs’ traffic is just an estimate, so it shouldn’t be used in isolation. The metrics I would look at are ranking keywords, traffic history, country, relevancy, and pages driving traffic. DR and traffic are good indicators, but what really counts is the keyword profile and relevancy of content.
Mkrtechsoft said:
I think DR is not much important, because its a third party metrices. For backlinks, Organic traffic and relevancy of your niche is the most important things.
Click to expand...
Agreed. DR is just a third-party tool, and hence, I would not evaluate a site solely on the basis of its DR.

Instead, organic traffic, relevance, content quality, and backlink profile are much more relevant in this context.
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top