Testing Reddit's New Filters Together.

i wont mention the domain but the domain i promoted was almost as big as amazon domain itself and in fact reddit used to give special treatment to this domain and when i saw it didnt get through i knew it was over completely for reddit.
so nothing is getting through the filters. even reddit.com links themselves wont pass now someone said

what level account you testing on? mine are like maybe 6 months old but they were warmed up with a few non promotional activity slowly over MONTHS before i did the activity. i havent tried with some super high level account. not sure what level your accounts are. but if i cant get through on these accounts its not worth the effort cause it takes alot of work to warm up each one
I buy accounts but currently only working with ones up to 1000 karma and up to 2 months old. As I said, Reddit is now using a bunch of different filters, so it might be a combination of the account activity, account age and link quality. If most of the links are removed, we have to test different accounts with different activities and from different devices. You can maybe try 3 different accounts from 3 different devices and IPs posting similar posts (but not the same) and try to add the same link to some website with reputation. And then see if all 3 will be removed.
 
hey all.. just here to share my experience around the new filters:
- we were using ai to generate comments for helpful posts in bulk for last 2 years... and it was really really good. It genuinely felt like a real user sharing their experience in the most general way (im sort of an llm / ai engineer so I know how they work)
- obviously July hit us hard.

Here are some things that still show potential:
0. warmup is key - that goes without saying
1. directly posting our comment from our system resulted in a ban. But if we post a comment (without any product plug) and edit it a day later. its chance of survival goes seriously high.
2. if your product can survive bad mouthing along with 2,3 other competitors you should try it. (basically no pr is bad pr)
3. we are experimenting with image based comments now.

Also im looking for reddit experts who sell warmed up accounts / do reddit commenting if I give the comment. lmk if you can help
 
hey all.. just here to share my experience around the new filters:
- we were using ai to generate comments for helpful posts in bulk for last 2 years... and it was really really good. It genuinely felt like a real user sharing their experience in the most general way (im sort of an llm / ai engineer so I know how they work)
- obviously July hit us hard.

Here are some things that still show potential:
0. warmup is key - that goes without saying
1. directly posting our comment from our system resulted in a ban. But if we post a comment (without any product plug) and edit it a day later. its chance of survival goes seriously high.
2. if your product can survive bad mouthing along with 2,3 other competitors you should try it. (basically no pr is bad pr)
3. we are experimenting with image based comments now.

Also im looking for reddit experts who sell warmed up accounts / do reddit commenting if I give the comment. lmk if you can help
So you're only doing comments? No posts? What kind of accounts are you using - how many karma and age?
 
I buy accounts but currently only working with ones up to 1000 karma and up to 2 months old. As I said, Reddit is now using a bunch of different filters, so it might be a combination of the account activity, account age and link quality. If most of the links are removed, we have to test different accounts with different activities and from different devices. You can maybe try 3 different accounts from 3 different devices and IPs posting similar posts (but not the same) and try to add the same link to some website with reputation. And then see if all 3 will be removed.
so some of your links are sticking? i only had 2 stick and i couldt figure out why they did cause one had spam history and the other didnt.
all the rest attempts in the last week led to removals or bans so it wasn tworth the headache
my accounts are more then 6 months old and the warmup process is slow over months but i dont do a ton of warmups you do more then me cause its nore like single digits or double digits karma but i do a few so it does look natural cause its slow and im waiting months before doing prmotion
 
so some of your links are sticking? i only had 2 stick and i couldt figure out why they did cause one had spam history and the other didnt.
all the rest attempts in the last week led to removals or bans so it wasn tworth the headache
my accounts are more then 6 months old and the warmup process is slow over months but i dont do a ton of warmups you do more then me cause its nore like single digits or double digits karma but i do a few so it does look natural cause its slow and im waiting months before doing prmotion
It's very hard to post links anymore, even with adding the links in the edit, they are getting removed. I'd like to hear from someone who manage to do it, where's the catch?
 
It's very hard to post links anymore, even with adding the links in the edit, they are getting removed. I'd like to hear from someone who manage to do it, where's the catch?
the 2 that stuck were straight up link drops but all edits ive tried were remove even ones that were up to 1 to 2 months old comments i edited didnt matter and most link drops removed and in fact i got a few accounts banned testing straight link dropping so its unsustainable
 
I never thought Reddit going to be like Yelp!

Still, the accounts I manage using iPhone are going well. But it's pretty expensive to manage all the accounts on an iPhone!
 
I never thought Reddit going to be like Yelp!

Still, the accounts I manage using iPhone are going well. But it's pretty expensive to manage all the accounts on an iPhone!
So, you can normally post links if you're doing it on iPhone? You grew up all the accounts on iPhone from zero? How do you manage all the accounts on iPhone only?
 
So, you can normally post links if you're doing it on iPhone?
I did one paid post two months ago, and still it sticks - no drop. I already have a few Reddit works pending. I am warming up accounts for those projects. Will update here later how it goes.


You grew up all the accounts on iPhone from zero?
Absolutely - from the level zero!

How do you manage all the accounts on iPhone only?

It's expensive! Unless I work for 4-5 clients simultaneously, it won't be profitable. Already two clients paid me, and it's been a month, and I'm still warming up the account to post. I will update the result soon!
 
We keep seeing the same comments over and over. We all know Reddit has become much stricter lately. The purpose of this thread is to test different methods and share the results, so we can figure out what works and avoid getting our accounts banned.
device and browser fingerprint is huge. reddit flags accounts posting from diff devices even with same ip or proxy rotation. also if your account looked inactive then suddenly gets busy that triggers their detection. pacing matters just as much as content

aged accs help but reddit's watching behavior patterns way more now. had a 3yr old one with decent karma that still got hit for jumping into unfamiliar subreddits too fast. real engagement on the platform first before posting seems to be what works, not just account age alone
 
Last edited by a moderator:
my personal account is shadow banned, 5+ years great karma such BS just because I used Grok Bot to help me manage it. Net Net manual management is the only way to go now...
 
fresh mobile 5G CGNAT + new account and still removed for filters, also on GoLogin for some reason.
 
I copy pasted a post from one sub to another and got it removed and then shadowbanned.

It was ok to do that before now not even once and it's dead.
 
did you guys seen a new update promotional comment gets removed by mod like not mod specifically how can a mod be so active like comments gets removed and shows this message like removed by mod then the account gets banned instanly
 
did you guys seen a new update promotional comment gets removed by mod like not mod specifically how can a mod be so active like comments gets removed and shows this message like removed by mod then the account gets banned instanly
It's Reddit's filters. They've had a huge update in the past couple of months. From what I can see, the auto mod for the subreddit bans posts if the user posting it has an account history of promo comments, low quality score, new account, broke subreddit's rules etc. If that gets missed then Reddit's own filters act as a second layer and delete the comment for the same reasons.

It's a black box, now they're using AI to moderate the site, it's extremely difficult to beat because that AI has been trained on hundreds of millions of promo posts, spam posts, bot posts, dodgy account behaviour and so on. Unless you were set up well before these new filters came into place, it's nigh on impossible now to get promo posts to stick, and I think, even if you were set up before these filter updates it's only a matter of time before you're caught up in the net as well in future updates.
 
I'm struggling with this shit too, unfortunately most people talking about Reddit here are bots and AI spammers, but I'm sure there are some human beings to share some knowledge

My next test will be trying more white hat niches to check if they are only monitoring black hat ones or if it's general and we are totally cooked
I am testing method to run multiple Instagram account in a single android devices
 
Are we coocked Venusaur? All my accounts are banned.
I think we are after the removed by mod reddit filter

It's Reddit's filters. They've had a huge update in the past couple of months. From what I can see, the auto mod for the subreddit bans posts if the user posting it has an account history of promo comments, low quality score, new account, broke subreddit's rules etc. If that gets missed then Reddit's own filters act as a second layer and delete the comment for the same reasons.

It's a black box, now they're using AI to moderate the site, it's extremely difficult to beat because that AI has been trained on hundreds of millions of promo posts, spam posts, bot posts, dodgy account behaviour and so on. Unless you were set up well before these new filters came into place, it's nigh on impossible now to get promo posts to stick, and I think, even if you were set up before these filter updates it's only a matter of time before you're caught up in the net as well in future updates.
have you found any solution to it yet?
 
I can make accounts that do not get banned, but I am struggling to find a service to deliver reliable upvotes. Any help guys?
 
Back
Top