What SEO automation did you give up on?

DaWanderer

Newbie
Joined
Oct 31, 2023
Messages
25
Reaction score
6
Ever try to automate something in your SEO workflow, only to give up and go back to doing it manually?
I'm curious what you tried to automate and what made you abandon it. If you're still doing it manually, how much time does it take each week?
 
Ever try to automate something in your SEO workflow, only to give up and go back to doing it manually?
I'm curious what you tried to automate and what made you abandon it. If you're still doing it manually, how much time does it take each week?
The bigger challenge is getting Google to index and properly understand all that content. There are a lot of technical things involved, especially building small niche-specific tools and internal systems to support the content and improve indexing. That's the part I've found much harder to automate.
 
Ever try to automate something in your SEO workflow, only to give up and go back to doing it manually?
I'm curious what you tried to automate and what made you abandon it. If you're still doing it manually, how much time does it take each week?
automation works great if u do it properly or have the right source. it can save so much time if u have the right setup that doesn't break.
 
I gave up on fully automated keyword clustering. It kept grouping terms that looked similar but had totally different intent.
 
I tried automating link prospecting, but the results needed so much filtering that it barely saved time. I’m back to doing it manually, around 2–3 hours a week.
 
Link prospecting, same as above. spent a year on scrapers and filters trying to build my own target lists for GSA and the maintenance ate every hour the automation saved. The sites die, the engines change, the list you scraped in March is half dead by June. I gave that part up and now I just buy a verified list. tried a couple of the premium ones, they all have ups and downs and still need my own filters on top, but that is an hour a week instead of a weekend and it costs less than the proxies I was burning on scraping.

The part I never gave up on is the building itself. That runs on its own and always has. What people usually mean when they say they abandoned automation is that they automated the judgement part, which tool goes on which page, what anchor, what tier, and that was never the bit worth automating. Automate the typing, keep the thinking manual, and it holds up fine
 
Ever try to automate something in your SEO workflow, only to give up and go back to doing it manually?
I'm curious what you tried to automate and what made you abandon it. If you're still doing it manually, how much time does it take each week?
I have ceased to use the automatic internal links. I was receiving some strange link being put into my text, and it took me way too long to fix them, in contrast to the 30 minute it would take me to make the link manually.
 
I have abandoned any automation of the updating process of content and linking. The tools can do the basics, but they lack the understanding of context; therefore, manual review is my preference.
 
Ever try to automate something in your SEO workflow, only to give up and go back to doing it manually?
I'm curious what you tried to automate and what made you abandon it. If you're still doing it manually, how much time does it take each week?
Content briefs that were automated was what I gave up on. It may have saved me time initially but i always seemed to be getting the same angles so now I prefer taking twenty minutes to check out the SERPs myself.
 
I automated pretty much 100% of my entire seo operations starting from topical coverage to outreach. We are living in strange times. Tasks that were taking hours, and days of my life span, can now be fully automated from A to Z.
 
i think the problem starts when automation is making the judgement, not just doing the repetitive work

with keyword clustering or link prospecting one wrong decision can get repeated hundreds of times before you even notice it

id automate the boring execution part but still keep the final judgement manual
 
I have been doing 100% automation for decades and time to time when the tool methods change / things change it adds some manual work but 99% of the time it does have a workflow now my all tasks doing my agents they are writing blog posts then creating link building campaigns for different SEO automation tools like GSA SER by changing models / agents via Hermes / Claude code
 
@Mrwhitex same with prospecting. what i gave up on was making my own web 2.0 accounts with scripts, captchas and phone verifies killed it, now i let the tool do the platforms it can and skip the rest. the part that never needed me is tier 2, thats been running by it self for years
 
You first need to do the job well yourself, identify the repetitive tasks, and automate them. That’s how you succeed. Otherwise, you just end up automating chaos.

PS I love n8n automation )
 
i tried automating internal linking but it kept suggesting links that technically matched while making no sense for the reader. i'd rather spend the extra time doing that part manually.
 
Fully automated outreach is rarely worth it because poor prospect filtering and generic personalization create more cleanup than manually reviewing a focused shortlist.
 
What helped me was clearly understanding what I'm doing and why. Automation isn't magic it's a continuation of growth.
Once you have clear, proven actions that work, you don't need to spend hours manually or hire someone you just automate them.
And when you weigh the benefits and it's genuinely worth it, you can spend a month or even six months on it.

I'm noticing that with the rise of AI, more and more people want a "magic button" and dive into complex coding, even though they don't have a working chain of actions yet and many of them end up giving up.
AI is a great assistant when you know exactly what you need it for.
 
the context was always off and needed manual fixes anyway. Still do it manually, takes about 2 hours a week but the quality difference is worth it.
 
tried automating outreach personalization and it was a disaster, every tool either produced generic garbage that got ignored or required so much manual rewriting to fix that it wasn't saving any time.
 
Back
Top