Still Editing Old Reddit Comments to Add Links/Brand Mentions?

Mondu Agency

Elite Member
Jr. VIP
Joined
Feb 25, 2025
Messages
1,522
Reaction score
204
If you're still using the old Reddit comment edit trick, I'd be careful with it. The method was pretty simple: write a useful comment, let it get some upvotes, wait a few days, then edit it and add your link or brand mention.

This used to work pretty well, but lately it seems to be getting caught much more often. The pattern is easy enough to spot. A normal comment gets posted, gets some traction, and then a few days later the comment suddenly has a promotional link or brand mention added to it.

Once moderators start looking at the edit history, it's pretty obvious what happened.

Doing it once might not mean much, but repeating the same thing across different subreddits can make the pattern pretty easy to identify.

Reddit has changed quite a bit over the last year or two, and some of the old promotion tactics just don't seem to have the same shelf life anymore.

So I'm curious what everyone else is doing now.

If you've found a better approach or a newer way of getting visibility on Reddit without relying on these old tricks, share it. Would be useful to hear what is actually working for people these days.
 
All of my posts that contain links or promotional content get removed. It’s really disappointing to see the current state of Reddit.
 
I tested many things nothing seems to work anymore
It’s just that blatant promotion is being suppressed. You need to properly build your account’s history and make sure not to exceed more than 1 promo post for every natural/organic content you post.
 
Creating value-first posts (like detailed case studies or teardowns) with an unlinked brand mention in the main text works far better than editing old comments for sneaky backlinking.
 
I’m still using this method in some subs, in the end it also depends on how active/stingy the moderators are. I haven’t noticed a huge difference in accounts getting burned so far.
 
I think Reddit end is near the filters, new updates daily, sudden no reason ban with all the content of that account removed. Then, not renewing the google deal, cheap ai systems to manage the platform and tyen gpt citation drop by 70% says all that reddit is not gonna maybe it will for 6 months 1 year but. I think our employment from reddit is going to end is near. :weep:
 
yeah the edit trick is dead. what i notice tho is reddit doesnt flag aged accounts nearly as hard. if u got a real 3-4 year old account with actual history they let u slide more than new ones. so instead of tricks just build proper aged accounts
 
If you've found a better approach or a newer way of getting visibility on Reddit without relying on these old tricks, share it. Would be useful to hear what is actually working for people these days.
I use a three account methodology where each account has a personal.

My brand for official kind posts.

A fan girl who is always glowing about the product and dropping it in other suitable threads

and a troll who boosts the fan girl post by trolling her and the brand. These an art and some psychology to making the troll work but it’s not hard.
 
yeah the edit trick is dead. what i notice tho is reddit doesnt flag aged accounts nearly as hard. if u got a real 3-4 year old account with actual history they let u slide more than new ones. so instead of tricks just build proper aged accounts
Do you recommend using a proxy?
 
Yeah, now edits like that seem to get picked up much faster. I've had better luck just contributing normally and only mentioning something when it genuinely fits the conversation.
 
yeah ive noticed the same thing. adding a link later changes the whole context of the comment, especially when the edit comes well after it was posted. feels like thats getting easier to spot now
 
Editing old comments to sneak in links is too risky now. Better to mention the brand naturally when it actually fits the discussion and only link where the subreddit allows it.
 
Reddit algorithms aggressively suppress direct promo links now. To bypass instant removals, keep all subreddit posts strictly informational and move link distribution to your personal profile bio or indirect branded mentions
 
Last edited:
Yeah, now edits like that seem to get picked up much faster. I've had better luck just contributing normally and only mentioning something when it genuinely fits the conversation.
Yeah that's the proper way to do that, otherwise your account will get flagged very easily/quickly.
 
Back
Top