Need Advise on Building YouTube Comment Account Farm

kyamuddinabdelmajeed

kyamuddinabdelmajeed

Newbie
Joined
Jul 27, 2026
Messages
4
Reaction score
2
As the title suggests I am trying to learn how to create or harvest a rotating 20-50 YouTube accounts for the purpose of self promotion of my videos. I would like these to be on rotation constantly but very selectively and seldom commenting to warm up the accounts. The biggest hurdle is getting the comments to "stick" meaning they appear in the top comments and not in the "newest" which is a filter essentially. Will new accounts work for this or it requires aged? Will I need proxies? Anyone done anything of the sort that can shed some light, would be greatly appreciated.
 
Advertise on BHW
Since new accounts lack credibility. t is likely that all comments posted will be filtered out anyway. I would concentrate on creating an authentic following base instead of changing accounts, as it will be harder to do so now since platforms are becoming smarter.
 
Why is it that people don't understand that the only thing that counts on youtube is good regular content? Your going to use proxies, and "warm up accounts"? Guess what google can see through all that shit. The only way you can win at youtube is to make good content. Perhaps you don't want to face this reality, and you'd rather waste time and money looking for that "special hack secret"? lol
 
conolly34 said:
Since new accounts lack credibility. t is likely that all comments posted will be filtered out anyway. I would concentrate on creating an authentic following base instead of changing accounts, as it will be harder to do so now since platforms are becoming smarter.
Click to expand...
my thought exactly but if you still want to try it use a good proxy and start small till you can go full on it
 
Okay gentlemen good suggestions and thank you for the contributions, anyone else?
 
hmm new accounts usually dont have much trust organic engagement tends to work better than trying to boost comments with multiple accounts.
 
Growing a channel around a clear niche can attract the right viewers without relying on artificial methods
 
As many said, youtube is terrible for your idea. Try to focus on creating quality content (even if you use ai to create, that's not a problem) because if youtube comments really worked, almost all smm panels that offers then would be selling a lot.
 
For YouTube, creating multiple accounts without proper authorization will only lead to unstable and inauthentic accounts. Focus on building quality content, finding your target audience, and attracting potential customers; it will be more effective.
 
tubeboost said:
Just create 20-50 accounts manually and farm from any anti-detect browsers, set likes to your own posts and reply the them. Give it some time. Write funny comments on popular videos to gain likes from other people.
Click to expand...

Thank you. Probably the only human to reply LOL other AI farming posts to scam others probably later. Sad world we live in.
 
kyamuddinabdelmajeed said:
As the title suggests I am trying to learn how to create or harvest a rotating 20-50 YouTube accounts for the purpose of self promotion of my videos. I would like these to be on rotation constantly but very selectively and seldom commenting to warm up the accounts. The biggest hurdle is getting the comments to "stick" meaning they appear in the top comments and not in the "newest" which is a filter essentially. Will new accounts work for this or it requires aged? Will I need proxies? Anyone done anything of the sort that can shed some light, would be greatly appreciated.
Click to expand...
From what I've seen, the bigger issue isn't whether the accounts are new or aged—it's whether the activity looks authentic. YouTube is pretty good at detecting coordinated engagement, so trying to rotate multiple accounts for self-promotion often ends up with comments getting filtered or receiving little visibility.

If your goal is to build an audience, I've had better results by participating genuinely in communities related to my niche, leaving thoughtful comments where they're actually relevant, and focusing on improving the video's title, thumbnail, and content. It tends to be a much more sustainable approach over the long term.
 
You can use Aged accounts and good proxies, but remember that YouTube is always updating its algorithm. Always stay updated to prevent loss on your investment.
 
It’s not really about whether the account is new or aged. What matters is making it look real and building some trust with YouTube. You can use an antidetect browser with clean proxies to manage them. Spend some time browsing in the niche first. Let the accounts build some normal activity before commenting.
 
Panther28 said:
The only way you can win at youtube is to make good content.
Click to expand...
Not even necessarily "good" content. Just stuff that the algorithm favors. Let face it... there's a lot of turds floating to the top of YouTube these days - while a lot of good content is getting buried and barely pushed.
 
Make sure each account runs isolated in terms of IP/fingerprint, so when one of them gets flagged it doesn’t drag the rest of the botnet along with it.
 
The best way would be building something that’ll run headless, it’ll require a bit more work since you need to be able to decompile frameworks, but imo it’s the only real solution to a stable running environment.
 
Most of the thread has answered the account half of your question, so here's the other half, which is what actually orders the top comments. That slot isn't a trust ranking, so account age and proxies don't touch it. It's ordered mostly by engagement on the comment itself, likes and replies, weighted by how early the comment landed under the video. Twenty accounts each leaving one careful comment and then going quiet is, by definition, the shape that stays in newest.

That leads somewhere uncomfortable. The only lever that lifts a comment is other accounts engaging with it, and that's the pattern the filter was built to catch. Older accounts and clean proxies keep the accounts alive, they don't make comments stick. If what you want is visibility rather than volume, the cheaper version is timing, so comment early on videos that are still climbing, on channels whose audience actually replies, because one reply from a real viewer moves that ranking further than the votes you control.

Best,
Floqal
 
Top comments part is the tricky bit. There’s no magic account age or proxy setup that guarantees a comment will stay there. From my experience, comments that actually get replies and genuine interaction have a much better chance of getting visibility than comments posted from a stack of fresh accounts
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top