YouTube Ads vs TikTok Ads — which is actually better for top of funnel?

C

CosmicBanana

Newbie
Joined
Apr 30, 2026
Messages
13
Reaction score
15
Running a test for a health supplement brand. Decent budget, top-of-funnel awareness goal, eventually want to retarget for conversion. YouTube: Using skippable in-stream. Getting views cheap but the audience quality for retargeting feels thin. People watch 5 seconds and bounce.TikTok: Better engagement but harder to retarget since the ecosystem is more closed. Anyone have a framework for which platform to use based on product type/audience? My gut says TikTok is better for younger demo (18-34) and YouTube scales better for 35+ especially with longer-form content. Also has anyone tried running the same creative on both and compared? Curious if video that works on TikTok dies on YouTube or if good creative is just good creative.
 
Advertise on BHW
TikTok wins for 18-34 engagement, but for supplements, YouTube scales better for 35+; just don't copy-paste creatives, as TikTok style feels too organic for YouTube In-Stream placement.
 
I think the platform depends a lot on the product and creative style. TikTok is great for fast attention and discovery, while YouTube usually works better when you need more explanation and trust.
 
to be honest yeah i think every platform is different and i would use the same creative as a starting point then make small changes based on the results because testing is the only way to know what works best.
 
For supplements I would test both. TikTok can get cheap reach, while YouTube may bring better quality users for retargeting.
 
Tiktok is good for reaching new people, but youtube can bring better quality traffic. I would test both with a small budget and see which one gives better results.
 
i think it depends on the audience and creative becuase tiktok is great for younger users and quick content and youtube can work better for trust and longer videos adn I will test both and compare the quality of traffic not just views.
 
yeah i think it depends on the audience and creative style because tiktok usually works well for younger audiences and quick content and youtube can be better for trust and longer videos and testing both is the best way to known.
 
For me, the best approach would be testing both with small budgets first. The data usually shows which platform brings better quality visitors.
 
yeah i think tiktok works better for younger audiences and youtube is better for longer content and building trust because testing the same creative on both is the best way to see what performs better.
 
CosmicBanana said:
Running a test for a health supplement brand. Decent budget, top-of-funnel awareness goal, eventually want to retarget for conversion. YouTube: Using skippable in-stream. Getting views cheap but the audience quality for retargeting feels thin. People watch 5 seconds and bounce.TikTok: Better engagement but harder to retarget since the ecosystem is more closed. Anyone have a framework for which platform to use based on product type/audience? My gut says TikTok is better for younger demo (18-34) and YouTube scales better for 35+ especially with longer-form content. Also has anyone tried running the same creative on both and compared? Curious if video that works on TikTok dies on YouTube or if good creative is just good creative.
Click to expand...
Youtube can be good for older audiences because people spend more time watching longer videos. TikTok usually works better for younger users.
 
I’d suggest testing both with the same creative and comparing engagement and conversions and also tiktok may work better for younger audiences and also youtube can give better scale.
 
Maybe try shorter versions of the creative on TikTok and a slightly longer version on YouTube. The same video doesn’t always work equally well on both.
 
Try TikTok first for younger audiences and check the engagement quality before increasing the budget.
 
I would test both because TikTok can be better for younger audiences and quick hooks while YouTube works well for trust and longer education so just use the same idea, but adapt the creative to each platform and also don’t just copy paste.
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top