Print on Demand vs DropShipping

C

ContentCreator8

Regular Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2024
Messages
247
Reaction score
116
If you have to start Print on Demand or DropShipping in 2026 - what will you choose? I came across many Youtube videos where it is mentioned that Print on Demand and DropShipping are dead in 2026.

Share your thoughts please.
 
Advertise on BHW
They are both not dead. Print on demand needs creativity, creativity in the idea , creativity in design and dropshipping needs winning products, reliable supplier and fast delivery.
You gotta have those 2 or you are hardly gonna make any money.
 
Dropshipping requires experience, whereas Print on Demand is easy to start.
 
youtubers say everything is dead just to sell their new course on the next big thing... ignore them. neither is dead but the low effort stuff definitely is.

if i had to start fresh now id probably go with pod but only if you have a solid traffic source lined up, like tiktok organic or a highly specific niche. dropshipping is still viable but dealing with payment processors, chargebacks, and supplier speed is a nightmare if you dont know what you are doing. pod has worse margins but way fewer headaches.
 
honestly the model matters way less than people think at this point. both can still print money, the bottleneck now is creative and traffic, not whether its pod or ds.

if i was starting clean id lean pod too but mostly cause cashflow is easier when you dont have to front inventory or eat returns on physical goods. one thing nobody mentioned... the real money in dropshipping moved to branded/private label style stuff, the random aliexpress general store thing is what actually died, not dropshipping itself. people see those dead stores and assume the whole thing is gone.

pod margins are rough though, no way around it. you need volume or a niche where people will pay premium (pet stuff, hobbies, fandom etc). if you cant get cheap eyeballs neither one saves you so id figure out the traffic part before picking the model honestly.
 
the "dead" thing gets posted every single year lol. been hearing pod is dead since like 2019.

both still work but i agree the gap now is traffic not the model. if you can get cheap eyeballs you can sell almost anything, if you cant neither one saves you.

one thing id add for pod since nobody really touched it... the platform matters more than people give it credit for. printful/printify margins are getting squeezed but if you find a niche supplier or go semi local you can actually breathe a bit. the design side is where most people quit honestly, they slap some generic text on a shirt and wonder why nothing sells. you kinda have to live in whatever niche you pick.

ds i wouldnt touch as a beginner anymore tbh. payment processors will hold your money the second you get a spike in volume and good luck explaining chargebacks to stripe. branded stuff is the move but that needs upfront cash so its not really the "start with nothing" thing people want.

if it was me right now... pod, narrow niche, organic tiktok till something hits, then scale paid. nothing fancy.
 
I recently watched YouTube videos that showed people doing Print on Demand and making any where between $100 and $5000 within 3 months of starting it. What I see consistently is the fact that these people advertise their shop. Whether it is through paid advertising on Etsy, or through running Facebook ads if they have a shopify account connected to their Print on Demand account. A few videos showed people lost more than they made, and it really depended on the product they were selling. All of these Youtubers did their research though. They literally focused on selling products that met an emotional or physical need. For example, health supplements, dieting supplements, self-help books, etc. They touch on a pain point, and to be frank, its has been the same thing since the 2000's when I first got into internet marketing. It has not changed.
 
In my opinion, you need creative ideas and familiarity with the platform's traffic rules. However, before that, don't blindly follow YouTube master classes and the chorus of praise in the comment section.
 
Youtubers have been saying dropshipping is dead since like 2017 lol. It's just clickbait so they can sell a course on whatever the new meta is.

If i had to start fresh today, I'd probably go with POD but with a twist. Don't just upload designs to Etsy and pray. You need to hijack micro-trends on tiktok or reddit before they blow up, print them fast, and ride the wave.

@CloudMerchant is right about the payment processor side of DS. Stripe will lock your funds the moment you scale, and if you don't have the cashflow to float those orders while they hold your money, you're dead in the water anyway. POD is safer for testing angles, even if the margins make you want to cry.
 
one thing that keeps getting glossed over here is the design/research time on pod actually counts as your cost. everyone talks margins like its just print price vs sell price but if you spend 3 weeks finding a niche and making designs that flop, thats real money you burned, just not on a spreadsheet anywhere.

i lean pod too for starting clean but id push back slightly on the "fewer headaches" thing. the headache just moves. ds you fight processors and suppliers, pod you fight platform saturation and copycats. the second something sells on etsy you got 40 people ripping your listing within a week. so its not really easier, just a different pain.

the branded ds point earlier is the real answer imo. thats where the actual money went. but yeah it needs cash so its not the start with nothing dream people want.

if youre truly broke and starting today... pod, pick a niche you actually know inside out so you're not guessing what sells, organic till something hits. dont touch paid till you got a winner.
 
Yeah the copycat thing @Adsmith2026 mentioned is the real killer with POD these days. You spend days researching a micro-niche, get a few sales, and some scraper bot has your design listed on redbubble and amazon by the next morning.

If you're starting fresh, the hybrid route is probably the only way to keep your sanity. Use POD to test the waters and see what actually gets clicks, but don't plan on staying there. The second you get a design that sells consistently, source it bulk and ship it yourself or use a 3PL. That's the only way you get those margins back and actually control the shipping times so stripe doesn't freeze your account.

Classic dropshipping with 3-week delivery times from random suppliers is basically just a quick way to get banned from payment processors now.
 
you need to find a niche. I recommend finding micro niches and having many stores around them
 
I'd pick Print on Demand. The margins can be lower, but building a brand around unique designs feels more sustainable than selling the same dropshipping products everyone else has. Neither is dead, they're just a lot more competitive now.
 
I feel if you have the right product, right audience and right budget and right ads guy , dropshipping can do wonders.
 
I started the AliExpress Facebook adverts drop shipping thing years ago selling one little love heart necklace.

I noticed that people were disappointed with their purchases when it arrived in a crappy little pouch. I then moved to holding a little bit of stock and bought some packing myself. It added a few pennies to the cost but was worth it.

Feedback improved and sales went up.

A combination on CVD, spiralling ad costs and apps like Shen eventually took me out of the game.

I would strongly recommend using it as a way to test products but then shift to finding your own supplier.

I moved into POD shortly after and have a Mug business. I run it slightly different with drops, scarcity and premium pricing.

I know a guy in the same niche as me and he literally sells one product with one design and makes multiple 6 figures a year. It’s clever marketing and properly niched down with a message to market fit.
 
neither are dead
i only have experience in dropshipping so ill say dropshipping
 
Houcinovic said:
you need to find a niche. I recommend finding micro niches and having many stores around them
Click to expand...
why find a niche not a product instead
or a problem then find the product
or an audience that doesnt have much competition then product
 
Nobody's said the quiet part: neither one is a business. They're both fulfilment methods. That's why "is X dead in 2026" never resolves - you're asking whether a shipping arrangement is dead.

What actually died is arbitrage. There was a window where the gap between AliExpress pricing and what a cold FB audience would pay was wide enough that the model itself was the edge. Ad costs ate it, everyone found the same suppliers, customers got educated. Gap closed.

So the question isn't POD vs DS. It's what's your unfair advantage, and which method fits it. A niche you live in and can design for - POD. A supplier relationship or cash to hold stock - branded DS.

@MasonBookwright's mug guy is the whole thread in one line. One product, one design, multiple six figures. The model was never the moat.
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top