Which backlink type is giving you results lately - niche edits or guest posts?

yeah the line between guest posts and niche edits is super blurry these days anyway. most of the guest posts you buy are just on bloated link farms that are basically glorified pbns.

for a new site, link velocity matters way less than your anchor text distribution. if you blast exact match anchors on niche edits right away you will get hit. i usually stick to brand and raw url anchors for the first few months. also if the page hosting the niche edit has zero organic traffic, its a waste of money no matter what the metrics say.
 
Advertise on BHW
One thing nobody mentioned... the niche edit you buy today might be fine, but you have no control over what happens to that page later. Seen pages that were clean get loaded up with 40 more outbound links six months down the line and tank everything pointing through them. At least with a guest post you placed the content, so the page stays somewhat predictable.

@SMM Junction nailed the anchor part though. People obsess over guest post vs niche edit and ignore that they are torching the site with money anchors way too early. Build some brand and url anchors first, get the site indexed properly, then worry about which link type pushes harder.

For a new site i'd honestly just go guest posts for the first few months and only touch niche edits once you find a page with actual traffic, not just a nice DR number. metrics lie, traffic doesnt.
 
Yeah @PixelDude is right about losing control. i had a killer niche edit on a high traffic page last year, pushed my keyword to page 1 in like two weeks. then six months later the seller sold 10 more links on that same page to casino and essay sites, completely tanked the page. Now if I do niche edits, I try to get the vendor to promise a strict OBL limit, though even then they lie half the time. For a brand new site I'd stick to clean guest posts first. Don't rush the velocity, just let the site breathe.
 
Nikolaos said:
How many guest posts and niche edits do you believe a new site should gain per week?
Click to expand...
There are no set numbers.

Niche and competitors must be analyzed to see the patterns.

But generally speaking I usually start slow and low (let's say 2 per week) and pick up the pace as weeks go by.
 
Rankings Daily said:
@faddy1000 edu links for a saas is kinda bait unless you have a legit reason for them to link to you, like a student discount page or some free calculator tool. google isn't stupid, if a random university resource page links to a b2b saas tool out of nowhere it looks sketchy as hell. i tried the scholarship method back in 2021 and got a bunch of edus, but most faded or got cleaned up by the webmasters after a year anyway.

honestly most "niche edits" you buy from the major marketplaces are just hacked sites or bloated networks. if you can find someone who actually does manual outreach and gets you inserted into a post that already gets real organic traffic, those hit way harder than any guest post. otherwise just stick to guest posts on actual active sites. costs more but you sleep better at night.
Click to expand...
Thank you. Right now making claude scripts to just work alongside semrush to pull relevant articles and will manually find those people on linkedin. Not really scalable but IMO enough to get traction
 
SMM Junction said:
For a new site I wouldn’t set it like “x per week” too strict. If it has no authority/traffic yet, 1-2 decent guest posts a month and maybe a niche edit here and there is enough imo. Bigger issue is anchors and relevance... people burn sites by doing 10 links with money anchors before the site even has content depth.

Niche edits can move stuff quicker, yeah, but I’d only use them on pages that actually have traffic or at least some real history. Random “aged page” with 300 outbound links is just rented trash most of the time.
Click to expand...
We have 15 DR and 3k /m traffic
 
yeah the quality difference between marketplace "niche edits" and actual curated outreach is night and day. most of the cheap ones you buy are just hacked sites or PBNs where the admin doesn't even know they have outbound links. that's why they get spammed with casino links later... but if you do the manual outreach yourself to real bloggers who have a relevant post, those links are gold. takes forever to get a reply but they actually survive core updates.
 
the main headache with niche edits is how hard it is to get genuine ones... if you are buying them off a sheet from a vendor, they are almost always hacked sites or pbn networks that will get nuked eventually. doing manual outreach for edits is a nightmare too because most real bloggers hate opening up old posts to add a link unless you pay them a stupid amount.

since you already have some traffic and a bit of authority, guest posts on active sites are just way easier to control. at least with a gp you control the surrounding text and anchor placement. niche edits can work wonders but only if you have the patience to scrape and pitch real webmasters yourself.
 
Same here tbh. Niche edits move faster, but guest posts feel way safer long term. Mixing both seems to be the sweet spot.
 
The WP Nerd said:
most of the cheap ones you buy are just hacked sites or PBNs
Click to expand...
The niche edit vs guest post debate is the wrong question. What matters is whether you still control the link in 12 months.

A vendor edit on a hacked site, you control nothing. The page changes, your link gets buried under newer content, or the site gets cleaned and it vanishes. You bought a snapshot, not an asset.

Guest posts you control a little more, but only if the host has real traffic and actually maintains the post. Most go stale.

Source class matters more than either label anyway. A profile that is all one type looks engineered. Mix them, vary the anchors, and weight it toward placements that survive.

The way I deal with decay is an owned network where I can edit the anchor or target when a page drifts, instead of watching the link rot on someone else's site. Different approach, but permanence is the whole point.
 
I've had good results with niche edits and guest posts on relevant sites. They tend to get indexed faster and pass more value than random profile or forum links. Quality and relevance have always mattered more than the number of backlinks.
 
Niche edits usually give fast SEO results whereas guest posts help in gaining more authority.
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top