How to Scale a Faceless Anime Channel? Need BHW Advice on CTR, Algorithm & Competitor Strategy

Hey BHW family,
I’ve recently launched a new faceless YouTube channel in an anime sub-niche, and I need some expert eyes on my situation.
The Format & Competitors:
The content is completely faceless, focusing on high-quality editing, voiceovers, and an anime comparison/list-style format. I know for a fact that this concept is highly profitable; there are a few competitor channels doing the exact same format and pulling in 100k to 500k views consistently. The demand and the audience are definitely there. (I'd prefer to keep the exact micro-niche private to avoid copycats, but it's a proven visual format).
My Current Stats:
On my latest uploads, YouTube is actually testing the waters. I’m getting about 1k to 1.5k organic impressions within the first 12–24 hours. The algorithm is trying to find my audience, which is a good sign.
The Problem:
My CTR is dead. It's hovering between 0.4% and 1.2%. Because of this, the algorithm stops pushing the videos further after the first day.
I'm trying to figure out what I am doing wrong compared to the established channels. Here are my questions for the BHW experts:
The CTR Psychology for Faceless Channels: For visual list/comparison niches, what actually triggers the click? My competitors' thumbnails look simple, but they get crazy views. Do you guys recommend high-contrast images, curiosity loops, or subtle clickbait? How can a new channel stand out visually against established ones?
Channel Authority vs. Algorithm: Does YouTube suppress new faceless channels in these niches until they build "authority," or is it purely a CTR + Retention game from day one?
Seeding & Push Tactics: To compete with established channels that already have loyal subscribers clicking on day one, should I rely 100% on organic search/suggested? Or is there a safe way to seed my videos (e.g., social signals, high-retention views) to show the algorithm that my content is worth pushing?
I would really appreciate any insights, strategies, or experiences you can share about growing faceless channels in competitive niches.
Thanks a lot!

1) CTR issue: Don't do heavy clickbait. Anime fans love curiosity loops. Analyze your top 3 competitors - pick their best-performing thumbnails from the last month, reverse-engineer their concepts, and make yours cleaner with higher contrast. Less text, more emotion/hype on the image.
2) Authority: No, YT doesn't suppress new channels. It’s pure math from day one. Your 1% CTR is just telling the system that people aren't interested, so it stops giving you impressions.
3) Seeding: Going 100% organic on a brand new channel in a highly competitive niche is playing on hard mode. Pure organic takes forever to trigger. Definitely seed your videos in the first 24 hours with some high-retention views and social signals to force the algorithm into the Top 10 search/suggested results. Once you get that initial push and target data, your organic traffic will take over if the content is solid.

TopOneYouTube said:

1) CTR issue: Don't do heavy clickbait. Anime fans love curiosity loops. Analyze your top 3 competitors - pick their best-performing thumbnails from the last month, reverse-engineer their concepts, and make yours cleaner with higher contrast. Less text, more emotion/hype on the image.
2) Authority: No, YT doesn't suppress new channels. It’s pure math from day one. Your 1% CTR is just telling the system that people aren't interested, so it stops giving you impressions.
3) Seeding: Going 100% organic on a brand new channel in a highly competitive niche is playing on hard mode. Pure organic takes forever to trigger. Definitely seed your videos in the first 24 hours with some high-retention views and social signals to force the algorithm into the Top 10 search/suggested results. Once you get that initial push and target data, your organic traffic will take over if the content is solid.

Click to expand...

Follow their advice as they made great pointers.

Also thing to note is CTR lower could also possibly be that the thumbnail you made are lower quality or it’s not fitting with the title and the thumbnail. From what I have seen in manga dubs or anime channels that I noticed is that, they both have this comparison of the characters development or full blown manga thumbnail with added detail for their thumbnails.

Since the competition is high in that niche, take note that you might want to be unique like make it your own kind of thumbnails and title. You can do what the other user suggests which is take someone’s thumbnails for notes but if you don’t have any ideas or can’t think of any, Google Gemini could help you brainstorm what thumbnails and let GPT image make a concept thumbnail. Then use that idea to make it your own using photoshop or photopea.

If you don’t want to take long form route yet, seed videos in short form then you can make full form videos also when you got sense of idea. Make sure to promote it outside of YouTube like instagram, etc.

Edit: I forgot to mention is that you don’t really need long tailed title, make the title as interesting and fit it with the suitable thumbnail to make viewers more interested

Already great pointers above here , what I can add to that is be consistent as the algorithm also rewards consistency .

The algorithm isn't suppressing you because you lack authority; it's dropping you because your CTR is sending a negative signal. 0.4% CTR on 1.5k impressions means only 6 people clicked. The algorithm just follows the audience.

fix the thumbnail first, everything else is secondary right now