CTR boosting decreased in the last month

[SirLouen]

I've observed that CTR boosting power has decreased in the last couple of months

I cannot explain it, I've been using multiple platforms like micro-workers, serpclix and ctrify lately and I feel that they are using bots or what-so-ever

It's so weird to read their claims like CTRify:



"The 3M workers selected group". WTF?

I wonder where these guys are sourcing such several workers. Botland? Carefully selected by Mr. AI Smith? TF?

Ultimately, it appears that everything drills down to only microworkers and harsher and more expensive every day. Looking for your thoughts. For Local SEO things are even worse, I have not done any CTR Boost in Local for almost 6 months already. Not saying that CTR doesnt work as many nabs are claiming, but I find that it's going uphill

 

[Ashk881]

I wonder where these guys are sourcing such several workers. Botland? Carefully selected by Mr. AI Smith? TF?

If they are to be believed. They are sourcing them from random "Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) centers" in Pakistan and India where they pay like 0.5$/hr for some person clicking through your Google searching for their customer's serps.

Tho, I don't think they are actually doing that. It's just too easy to lie to your customers and not miss the huge profit margins that come with 100% bots.

 

[hideath]

Relying only on CTR manipulation is probably a bad idea,
It's good enough to push you to the first page or/and first spots, from there you have to handle a good on-page & links that will keep your page(s) there,

You should also stick to micro workers, not only you can easily get scammed by some service sellers,
Using micro workers will get better and more diverse browsing history, IPs, chrome profiles, etc... much more likely to be spotted

 

[Grid Architect]

it ain't 2005

 

[hideath]

it ain't 2005

2005 you won't even need that, plain keyword stuffing will get you to page 1 in no time,
also, you probably shouldn't throw random comments if you don't have any recent and enough experience about this

 

[HenryObi]

2005 you won't even need that, plain keyword stuffing will get you to page 1 in no time,
also, you probably shouldn't throw random comments if you don't have any recent and enough experience about this

I've been conflicted on the topic of CTR boosting and its ability to improve ranking, is there a comprehensive case study on this or do you have an experience that shows it works. Quite a few people I've spoken to concluded with 'rankings usually drop afterwards'

 

[Schatten]

The main problem is making sure cookies are warmed up for CTR manipulation.

Using reliable 4G proxies of high quality leads to positive outcomes, as long as you have good ones.

However, I wouldn't depend on manipulating CTR for the long term.

 

[Mr Positive]

I tried it once for a client didn’t work at all. And now I feel Google is smart enough to detect it so probably try something else for your sites

 

[SirLouen]

If they are to be believed. They are sourcing them from random "Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) centers" in Pakistan and India where they pay like 0.5$/hr for some person clicking through your Google searching for their customer's serps.

How do they get US clicks from those farms? I assume they are maintaining a massive US proxy farm at the same time.

 

[sscaz]

I've observed that CTR boosting power has decreased in the last couple of months

I cannot explain it, I've been using multiple platforms like micro-workers, serpclix and ctrify lately and I feel that they are using bots or what-so-ever

It's so weird to read their claims like CTRify:

View attachment 310567

"The 3M workers selected group". WTF?

I wonder where these guys are sourcing such several workers. Botland? Carefully selected by Mr. AI Smith? TF?

Ultimately, it appears that everything drills down to only microworkers and harsher and more expensive every day. Looking for your thoughts. For Local SEO things are even worse, I have not done any CTR Boost in Local for almost 6 months already. Not saying that CTR doesnt work as many nabs are claiming, but I find that it's going uphill

there's a way to rank for 80% of the keywords with just ctr boosting, there are also several ways to boost your ctr naturally to 30%+, but sites like rapidworkers are good enough.

 

[SirLouen]

rapidworkers

I've seen that you have been a big praiser of CTR lately. So you are using microworkers right?
I used to use microworkers like 1 year ago, but I noticed that most of the piloted pages (the ones that used javascript to force timings and all that) started to drop
Now I see that people using microworker sites are relying 100% that the microworkers do the job straight away. For example: "Go to this site, wait 90 seconds, copy the code, paste it here". But the problem is that the 90s are pure faith, 99.9999999% of the people will copy the code, close the page and move on.

 

[hideath]

I've been conflicted on the topic of CTR boosting and its ability to improve ranking, is there a comprehensive case study on this or do you have an experience that shows it works. Quite a few people I've spoken to concluded with 'rankings usually drop afterwards'

That's the catch,
Your search(s) CTR will drop after stopping and rankings will drop in return, pretty much as removing a link (links) that was pushing you in SERPs,
Probably will stick for longer if more real users are clicking your links by the time you decide to stop, resulting in higher CTR than the beginning,

With the right formula is works with no problem,
But the thing is that you have to target the right niches/keywords, as it would need much more investments for high traffic low competition ones

How do they get US clicks from those farms? I assume they are maintaining a massive US proxy farm at the same time.

Proxies, probably VPNs, RDPs, etc...
It's not a perfect scenario, even if real users are involved, there's a ton of red flags

 

[SirLouen]

It's not a perfect scenario, even if real users are involved, there's a ton of red flags

3M talented guys from 105 countries.

I read it again and still blows my mind.

 

[Steven Davis1]

post first paragraph must be catchy.if you do well you got result immedietly

 

[hideath]

post first paragraph must be catchy.if you do well you got result immedietly

That's used to improved Users in page time not the search CTR,
Nothing much to do for the CTR apart from page meta title & description,
The rest is up to the users and branding

 

[SirLouen]

That's used to improved Users in page time not the search CTR,
Nothing much to do for the CTR apart from page meta title & description,
The rest is up to the users and branding

These are bots or semi-manual guys that are spamming the forum lately. They are pretty obvious to spot, their comments are very random.

 

[Enter_Adsman]

micro-workers

probbly they use shitty proxies and they just get detected by google

 

[wanderer.717]

do you do money keyword CTR boosting ? How much clicks per day u send?

 

[SEOMOOD]

CTR is a ranking factor in Google, but no public software produces results.

 

[sscaz]

I've seen that you have been a big praiser of CTR lately. So you are using microworkers right?

Noup, i make real people from vairous sources search for my keyword and click to my site, i'd share it even here if it isn't easily patchable to rank for 80% of keywords out there