Permanently Closed Marketplace Sales Thread
- Thread starter RCKid
- Start date
- Status
RCKid
Power Member
- Aug 15, 2009
- 532
- 89
Thanks!
RCKid
Power Member
- Aug 15, 2009
- 532
- 89
okay thanks
RCKid
Power Member
- Aug 15, 2009
- 532
- 89
thanks
RCKid
Power Member
- Aug 15, 2009
- 532
- 89
RCKid
Power Member
- Aug 15, 2009
- 532
- 89
- Jul 30, 2020
- 164
- 123
This service looks to be almost exactly what I am looking for. A bit pricey, but seems that it might be worth it. 
However, the above comment has me confused?
Wouldn't a main benefit of this service be to try and start a "conversation", meaning that you get one initial stronger comment and then several replies below that one?
Wouldn't then also be natural, (and very useful) to get a number of likes on both the main comment and a few of the replies?
According to your website you are offering likes on the video at an extra cost, couldn't you then also provide some comment likes at an extra cost?
I'm very interested in your service both for myself and potentially for a client, but at almost $1.50 per comment you need to try to get maximum value out of each comment, and I would think comment upvotes would be a part of that?
However, the above comment has me confused?
Wouldn't a main benefit of this service be to try and start a "conversation", meaning that you get one initial stronger comment and then several replies below that one?
Wouldn't then also be natural, (and very useful) to get a number of likes on both the main comment and a few of the replies?
According to your website you are offering likes on the video at an extra cost, couldn't you then also provide some comment likes at an extra cost?
I'm very interested in your service both for myself and potentially for a client, but at almost $1.50 per comment you need to try to get maximum value out of each comment, and I would think comment upvotes would be a part of that?
RCKid
Power Member
- Aug 15, 2009
- 532
- 89
This service looks to be almost exactly what I am looking for. A bit pricey, but seems that it might be worth it.
However, the above comment has me confused?
Wouldn't a main benefit of this service be to try and start a "conversation", meaning that you get one initial stronger comment and then several replies below that one?
Wouldn't then also be natural, (and very useful) to get a number of likes on both the main comment and a few of the replies?
According to your website you are offering likes on the video at an extra cost, couldn't you then also provide some comment likes at an extra cost?
I'm very interested in your service both for myself and potentially for a client, but at almost $1.50 per comment you need to try to get maximum value out of each comment, and I would think comment upvotes would be a part of that?
Naturally, we do that right now, especially on a comment that we posted that is funny. It would have 2-8 upvotes. This already comes with the service.
But we are not going to upvote a spammy comment that others posted. This is what people are mostly asking for.
"Hey check out bla blab albla." or
"I bought my blablabla from blablabla dot com."
"Check out my profile to get free blablabla"
It just puts our accounts in unnecessary jeopardy. (And this is why custom comments cannot be spammy like this as well.)
Just think about it, if YouTube catches on the spam comments that we promoted and realizes what profiles upvoted, it's over for us.
I've been working YouTube since 2008 and never had an issue with the accounts because I keep them as low profile as possible.
RCKid
Power Member
- Aug 15, 2009
- 532
- 89
Also, this is available on the website. When the commenters converse between each other or the uploader, they like each other's comments.
RCKid
Power Member
- Aug 15, 2009
- 532
- 89
Added new conversational options that can be added to orders:
Example (Targeted Comments Conversation) – Urban R&B Male singer music video:
Example (Targeted Comments Conversation) – Urban R&B Male singer music video:
- Kaylah Baker: Lord, please keep this fine man single til I find him in person
- MONAE: @Kayla Baker Chhhhhhhhhhhhhhiiiiiilllllllleeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
- Jul 30, 2020
- 164
- 123
Thanks for explaining and I understand completely now.
My thoughts/plans were as follow:
1. Find extremely targeted videos.
2. Comment from a high quality account with something that wouldn't be obviously spammy but still brings traffic:
"This video reminds me of xxxxxxx xxxxxx, (a rather specific phrase that someone can easily Google or search for on YouTube and will bring the relevant result), but I don't know whatever happened to that and never followed up on it."
or various well spun comments of the above, all comments hand-checked to make sure they are unique and also using a variety of keywords as the "specific keyword phrase" that they would search for.
3. The reply with a variety of replies that aren't too spammy but may improve interest like: "I heard of that but don't think it's real." etc.
4. I guess it's important to point out that we wouldn't be posting this under videos that are about a specific product or service, but rather more general videos covering that particular subject matter.
5. Obviously never post any links or directly ask anyone to click something etc.
In your experience working with YouTube for so long, do you think the above would work, or would it quickly get flagged as spam?
Would what I described above be something you would be willing to work with, or would you consider it too risky for your accounts? What about if we bought a few aged YouTube accounts/channels to try with at first and see how these type of comments are treated?
It is kind of hard to see any real benefit of the type of comment in your example above on a music video, other than the increased activity for that channel owner of course. But I mean as a means of trying to drive traffic from YT comments, but maybe that is not what your service should be used for?
- Status