I can get about 40 comment thumbs up on a any comment, so it will appear in top. Tested with minecraft, mw3, celeb niche, got only like 3 leads. I was hoping much more when comment (that looks pretty real) on selena gomez video with 100m views appears on top. I was inspired from this thread about celeb niche

http://www.blackhatworld.com/blackha...-friendly.html

So what do you think? Is this top comment thing worked out for anyone?

I used to bank $150-300/day with comment rating. Although it is a hard job to automate, it really paid off when I got it all working.

Resources such as accounts and proxies can be expensive, but it all pays off in the end if you keep working hard. I stopped doing it because I just do not have the time, but it is definitely a good income source.

Just my .2c

Originally Posted by izSpK

I used to bank $150-300/day with comment rating. Although it is a hard job to automate, it really paid off when I got it all working.

Resources such as accounts and proxies can be expensive, but it all pays off in the end if you keep working hard. I stopped doing it because I just do not have the time, but it is definitely a good income source.

Just my .2c

What do you mean by hard job, thumbs up lots of videos comments?

My comment is now top on very viral video which get comments every minutes/seconds not getting clicks, I think made some mistake in comment, they copy it wrongly.

What niche you was using? Gaming, celeb, movies..?

Originally Posted by sviedinys

What do you mean by hard job, thumbs up lots of videos comments?

My comment is now top on very viral video which get comments every minutes/seconds not getting clicks, I think made some mistake in comment, they copy it wrongly.

What niche you was using? Gaming, celeb, movies..?

More than likely because YOU see the comment is on the top, Check with a proxy to see if it's really on top because i doubt it is, If it was you'd be getting a pretty good amount of clicks on a viral video.

Note: On viral video's they'll go down within 5 minutes without a doubt.

Originally Posted by Ranger11

More than likely because YOU see the comment is on the top, Check with a proxy to see if it's really on top because i doubt it is, If it was you'd be getting a pretty good amount of clicks on a viral video.

Note: On viral video's they'll go down within 5 minutes without a doubt.

It is, and I am getting clicks, but not that much as expected. And it stayed long time, ill keep trying.

Originally Posted by sviedinys

It is, and I am getting clicks, but not that much as expected. And it stayed long time, ill keep trying.

If it stayed a long while, I would consider trying proxies to see if it is actually there. http://www.hidemyass.com/

Just double check.

hmm i think i might try this..

Originally Posted by izSpK

If it stayed a long while, I would consider trying proxies to see if it is actually there. http://www.hidemyass.com/

Just double check.

Yes, theyre are here, and im sure, using good YT PVA accounts and private proxies. On some viral minecraft video my top comment after 4 hours is still here, it pointed to another fresh video which got already over 100 views from there, and its offering minecraft premium accounts. I made pretty good landing page for it with CPA locker, but no conversations, I think need much more videos or change niche.

Originally Posted by sviedinys

Yes, theyre are here, and im sure, using good YT PVA accounts and private proxies. On some viral minecraft video my top comment after 4 hours is still here, it pointed to another fresh video which got already over 100 views from there, and its offering minecraft premium accounts. I made pretty good landing page for it with CPA locker, but no conversations, I think need much more videos or change niche.

i have the same problem as you do
i tried the celebrity thingy with content lock , got about 500 clicks to my link and 2 leads....that really sucks
what niche you guys think works good with comment rating ?

loL 500 clicks to link - never happened to me
I guess I have to work harder and harder and harder ;/

delay the content locker much longer, you have to tease them a little more... make them want it...

I have been doing a few test about comment voting.I´m trying to monetize traffic with clickbank. I tested a few free bots from here and some of them initially worked and all them are being caught, so I create my own bot which is very slow, but it gets the comments to the top. To sent like 30 votes it needs 45 mins. I´m testing on small time, niches and products, right now I only got 2 sales from 1.100 hops, and I needed like 25 comments to generate that traffic. It´s not bad as It´s a semiautomated process (well, you have to take one account, then login , then write the comment and finally put the bot to work) but I was expecting better results, to be honest as It suppose to be targetted visitors. I spin native speaker comments that I take from other videos, as my english is bad, so they are well written.

what is the best range in votes? I´m giving 20-30 votes to my comments and I thought that maybe 80 - 100 would look suspicious to YT users. The more votes more conversions?

I wish someone could point the best way to monetize comments as clickbank does not seem to be the best choice.

Thank you

Originally Posted by stallion45d

I have been doing a few test about comment voting.I´m trying to monetize traffic with clickbank. I tested a few free bots from here and some of them initially worked and all them are being caught, so I create my own bot which is very slow, but it gets the comments to the top. To sent like 30 votes it needs 45 mins. I´m testing on small time, niches and products, right now I only got 2 sales from 1.100 hops, and I needed like 25 comments to generate that traffic. It´s not bad as It´s a semiautomated process (well, you have to take one account, then login , then write the comment and finally put the bot to work) but I was expecting better results, to be honest as It suppose to be targetted visitors. I spin native speaker comments that I take from other videos, as my english is bad, so they are well written.

what is the best range in votes? I´m giving 20-30 votes to my comments and I thought that maybe 80 - 100 would look suspicious to YT users. The more votes more conversions?

I wish someone could point the best way to monetize comments as clickbank does not seem to be the best choice.

Thank you

CPA is probably the best choice. Social traffic is not too good for selling products, search traffic is obviously the best for selling clickbank products. as for votes, i simply do 5 more then the top comment just so you can out rank the competition

so whats this method?

basically you find a good popular video thats viral or being updated 5-10 mins ago with comments, and post up a comment related to the video with a cpa offer, then use a bot to auto vote your comment to the top ???

comment voting was good back in....around late 2010, cant believe people still try so hard to abuse it....

Originally Posted by phatzilla

comment voting was good back in....around late 2010, cant believe people still try so hard to abuse it....

so what methods are you doing ?

Originally Posted by stallion45d

I have been doing a few test about comment voting.I´m trying to monetize traffic with clickbank. I tested a few free bots from here and some of them initially worked and all them are being caught, so I create my own bot which is very slow, but it gets the comments to the top. To sent like 30 votes it needs 45 mins. I´m testing on small time, niches and products, right now I only got 2 sales from 1.100 hops, and I needed like 25 comments to generate that traffic. It´s not bad as It´s a semiautomated process (well, you have to take one account, then login , then write the comment and finally put the bot to work) but I was expecting better results, to be honest as It suppose to be targetted visitors. I spin native speaker comments that I take from other videos, as my english is bad, so they are well written.

what is the best range in votes? I´m giving 20-30 votes to my comments and I thought that maybe 80 - 100 would look suspicious to YT users. The more votes more conversions?

I wish someone could point the best way to monetize comments as clickbank does not seem to be the best choice.

Thank you

I just made the third sale on comment voting + clickbak. So the current rate is 400 hops / 1 sale. Btw, I don´t think this traffic is enough to make a decent amount with cpa, isn´t it?

Hey,
my problem is that links are not allowed - i have tried to change the /, without http ... but nothing works.

I think a adress like test(dot)com isn´t attractive, specially if you use link shortener like bitly

Originally Posted by Chuckzer

Hey,
my problem is that links are not allowed - i have tried to change the /, without http ... but nothing works.

I think a adress like test(dot)com isn´t attractive, specially if you use link shortener like bitly

make something like

ww w.google.com

It works and it is allowed

Originally Posted by Chuckzer

Hey,
my problem is that links are not allowed - i have tried to change the /, without http ... but nothing works.

I think a adress like test(dot)com isn´t attractive, specially if you use link shortener like bitly

have you tried bit.ly\yourlink?

change the / to \

always works for me

has anyone ever thought about to get people attention, is to link to a www.domain.com/image.jpg with a .htaccess redirect => offer ?

Originally Posted by EisaG

has anyone ever thought about to get people attention, is to link to a www.domain.com/image.jpg with a .htaccess redirect => offer ?

and what would this accomplish? just to get their attention? i dont understand. why dont you just link to your offer

Originally Posted by EmpireQuality

and what would this accomplish? just to get their attention? i dont understand. why dont you just link to your offer

because ppl wont just click on a any type of link...

Originally Posted by EisaG

because ppl wont just click on a any type of link...

yes, you are right. thats why you should use a domain or do bit.ly\catchywords

Originally Posted by EmpireQuality

yes, you are right. thats why you should use a domain or do bit.ly\catchywords

yea but a picture would be more catchy to the eyes, and it doesn't look spammy...

ex:

If a youtube vid was about a pet cat, doing all sorts of tricks etc.. and my comment would be:

"OMG, I've seen the same cat do the same thing, but this what happen to its owner face http://lolpixs.com/imageshack_003.jpg"

you're telling me that it wont get more clicks then a url shortner ?

its clear that its pointing to a real picture... so all, you have to do is, content lock that picture..

I've never tried something like this, with youtube because I just started trying to make $ with youtube.. but this same I use to cookie stuff on forums etc..

Thanks, the \ tip works, but only by bitly.

I would like to camouflage a adfly link with a url shortener link, but bitly doesn´t work with adfly (is on the black list).

Do you knwo a nother url shortener, who works on youtube (by \) and is compatible to adly?

Make sure to check if your comment is really at the top of the page. If you're using the same IP/proxy the comment was made with OR you're still logged into your account that made the comment, it can appear TO YOU ONLY that it is at the top. I use this site to check the result:

http://u2bp.com/

If it shows through that then it is definitely working.

Originally Posted by EisaG

yea but a picture would be more catchy to the eyes, and it doesn't look spammy...

ex:

If a youtube vid was about a pet cat, doing all sorts of tricks etc.. and my comment would be:

"OMG, I've seen the same cat do the same thing, but this what happen to its owner face http://lolpixs.com/imageshack_003.jpg"

you're telling me that it wont get more clicks then a url shortner ?

its clear that its pointing to a real picture... so all, you have to do is, content lock that picture..

I've never tried something like this, with youtube because I just started trying to make $ with youtube.. but this same I use to cookie stuff on forums etc..

there are many variables with your method though. getting the url to stick might be a bit of a problem. and i have never tried a method like this, it is interesting though. personally, i hate content locking. i think directly marketing a cpa offer is much better

Originally Posted by EmpireQuality

there are many variables with your method though. getting the url to stick might be a bit of a problem. and i have never tried a method like this, it is interesting though. personally, i hate content locking. i think directly marketing a cpa offer is much better

yea I agree with direct linking too, especially when dealing with high volumes of traffic.. but my method can direct link to offer as well.. I just thought it would of been much smoother to content lock the picture dealing with the niche instead of going to an offer that has nothing to do with the vid, unless the offer is niche'd based..

want to jv and test it out ?