Before I start I just want to say that this is information that I've tested myself. I use to make 900$ per day with YouTube on average posting 2000-3000 comments per day so I am very familiar with YouTube.

I had a freelancer make me a program which comments YouTube videos by signing in and out of accounts and posting 2 comments with each account. I hired an indian here on BHW and he made me 100 accounts for 12$.

In that week with my program I made about 3200$ and got SUPER screwed by YouTube. ALL my accounts were banned and so I got a new batch of accounts and they post comments , but my comments get marked as spam VERY soon and I only make about 150$ per day now.

Results from my testing:
-Once you are marked as "spammy" by YouTube , there's no going back.
Keep in mind youtube is owned by Google , the same company which made apps like Google Earth and the incredible search engine they have.

-Proxies , VPN's , different accounts and different browsers won't work. YouTube tracks EVERYTHING , mac address , ip adress , similarity in comments , accounts , track you using cookies and more which I probably don't even know about.

Solution:
Sorry to say but I've tried everything. Ive tried starting from scratch with private proxies only I had access to, and with accounts I created myself and completely revamping my comments and even bought a new domain. It seems as if there is no solution. I can't even create accounts with any different proxies I buy because YouTube recognizes proxies somehow and won't let me access the registration page. ( Try it yourself I'm not kidding)

As for posting tips:
- make your comments look realistic
- don't make them too long
- don't generalize them to a big niche , take the extra time to change sets of comments manually if your using a program. EG" instead of posting in the entertainment niche , try post for oprah winfrey and dr phil videos.
- keep it simple!

EDIT: I THINK I MAY HAVE A GOOD SOLUTION! When people were clueless about proxies with craigslist what did they do?WARRRRDRIVING. I'm getting my first vehicle since im now of legal age to drive(09 escalade) registered to my name on tuesday and so I will report back with my earnings and results. Will be changing domains , comments , accounts and even niche.

Advertise

I think better is comment from 1 account 100 times. I newer get banned, but also newer done more than few hundred comments with 2-4 accounts.

So in other words. Whatever you do, you're screwed? I do agree that they catch you very very fast. Good tips though, you have to make it realistic. Quality over quantity!

Very well put , youtube is about quality and niche targeted comments. And yes , whatever you do your eventually gonna get screwed

mafiaboy

do you spin comments so that each of them looks unique?

__________________
MISS Black Hat || I'm a girl, pls, do not call me "dude" :)))

oh btw, has anybody tested that? If two different accounts from diff IPs post the same (or 80-90% the same) comment, would the second YT account's comment be marked as spam?

I saw that funny thing with "Merry Christmas" marked as spam. just wondering...

__________________
MISS Black Hat || I'm a girl, pls, do not call me "dude" :)))

It's very useful post, thanks mafiaboy

I think that YT learned identify spam very quickly - this is not good)))

You must be doing something wrong, I know a guy that has posted well over 20.000 comments (Then he got banned) and he started up again with proxies and different domains for accounts and he's posting again 24/7.

good post mafiaboy. i had been baned from 5-7 acpunts so far in 2 weeks i always start again they always mark me as spam somehow.. youtube its geting to be like ebay )

I am posting about 500-600 comments everyday on only 20 accounts. It's about 30 spam comment/account per day. My accounts last for a month.

I am really suprised that youtube don't care about spam. They don't even care about user complaints - some of my profiles had many negative comments like "spammer as fuck", "yes i wanna win free iphone you dickhead"
Kinda funny

I have one question, when you say, you got a new batch of accounts, how did you get them? I mean, did you get them from the same guy like the last time? Perhaps he just screwed up, didn't clean his flash cookies, was too fast at registering or something like that and thereby your accounts got worthless.

And another question, is it even possible for a website, to get your mac adress? I mean, I can't think of any method (although I am far from being pro at web programming) and I just wonder, why so much websites still relly on cookies and IPs, when Mac adresses can be found out.

But good post, and well, to be carefull is always a good idea I think and that youtube gets smarter, we should make our comments more specific and proxies don't work, are useful informations in my opinion.

Do you use proxies, and do you use free or paid proxies?

I dont think this is strictly true because I posted lots of comments to one domain and a few to another domain I had. YT banned all my accounts, and I got some more, now the domain I posted lots of comments is marked as spam instantly so I changed the comments and now some (not all) dont get marked as spam. The other domain is the same but I changed the comments and lots are getting through with only few marked instantly as spam? so It is very strange maybe the more comments the harder the spam filter, but I wouldnt say its impossible to still make money from YT.

Youtube - Let your random side out

Today and yesterday I still spam with 10 accounts, 20 comments per 10 minutes with the same url(.)com as my previous banned comments and accounts. Non of them were marked as a spam! Maybe the spam filter will be turned on after Sunday or new year. Or it runs ones per week or days and delete all comments and accounts!

__________________
Fully Automated SEO Backlinks

"All You Need To Know About Commenting with YouTube" that's over exaggerated isn't it?

Im posting on videos with 15 million + views , and yes some comments to stick but not many.

mafiaboy, maybe they are not "too unique"?

__________________
MISS Black Hat || I'm a girl, pls, do not call me "dude" :)))

If I rotate between 4 comments or 10 it won't make a difference when your posting the amount I do , I still end up with hundreds of duplicate comments. I post about 3000 comments per day on average now to make 10x less than what I use to.

Hmm im not sure if i agree with all the points you made but either way it is quite interesting..Thanks!

google can't see your MAC, that is a myth.

i think youtube is no more gud to spam guys..i too lost all my accounts and now i m shifting to other videos sites like metacafe and dailymotion..HELL !

Yesterday I made about 750 comments with public proxies, 50 unique comments and 10 accounts. There are about 24 hours from then and I have no banned accounts, some marked as a spam comments and a lot of visits!

__________________
Fully Automated SEO Backlinks

Me too Posting in Youtube From Much Long time and i now am facing problems like account banned and i am unable to create accounts in youtube also..
I have used public proxies but no results for me.. I dont know how youtube track us....

Currently i am posting via shortening the url using tinyurl and bit.ly as already my domain as marked as spammy....

And atlast Youtube the best way of getting traffic.........

Let me know which proxies that your are using....

Here is what I do to comment successfully on yt.

1) Get a good YT Commenting bot with proxy support (recommend: myadtools.com)
there are more bots than just the one I recommended, or
- you can post comments using Imacros, search bhw for it.
- you hire some one to post comments for you
- you can do it your self manually.

2) Get good proxies (recommend: packetflip.com or yourprivateproxy.com)
- good proxies is the key, they should be used when creating account
and used when posting comments. ( get at least 50 proxies if you use bot)

3) Get good YT accounts
- get at least 100 yt accounts (if you use bot)
- you can get them on this forum, just find some one who can deliver them to you.
- ask the supplier how he makes the accounts, how many accounts he makes per ip (it's best if he uses 1 ip to per account)
- ask if he offers a 3 day replacement, if accs don't work he will replace them with working ones.

4) Posting comments
- post only 2 comments from a single account
- each comment should be different from the previous one (don't make duplicate comments, don't copy paste comments!)
- use variables if available ( spin phrases or text patterns so they don't repeat)
- mask your URL (mask it like: website,com ; website . com ; web site , com)
- don't always post your full url, use spaces ( smth like: web site , com)

5) Checking accounts
- DON'T LOGIN FROM YOUR IP TO CHECK ACCOUNTS!
- if you login to all of your accounts from your ip, yt will catch you and ban you
- instead use this YT account checker application created by Kimkils (virustotal scan)

6) Resolving captcha
- you can use good captcha solving services like:
1. deathbycaptcha.com
2. decaptcher.com
3. bypasscaptcha.com
4. beatcaptchas.com
- If you use a bot, then it has a built in captcha plugin
- If you post manually.. well then you just have type captchas in manually.


I hope this helps

I think is a paid proxies mate. No free proxy is that reliable.

YT account checker don't work for me. When I click on icon I get an error. Can you reupload it again? Thanks

That was very good post thank you for that. I am doing the exact same thing as you ( since a few months) but this method has failed me for the past 2 weeks. Although this is the ONLY and BEST way to post youtube comments so thanks given

I will report back on tuesday or wednesday afternoon with my experiences on war driving

Now concerning the MAC adress, I know it's impossible to get it off a visitor but it wouldn't surprise that those crazy programers there at Google Inc made it so they can track MAC adresses. Of course I can't be 100% sure , but I'm trying to be as paranoid as possible to try and figure out all of YouTube's ways of tracking us. We would of also said that to get a front view of every house in every big city in good quality would be impossible, but Google did it!

google can't track everything. . and honestly i think it actually likes a little bit of spam. It likes spam vids and spam comments. . cause not all of what we post is unliked. . there is a reason we post.

Your main complain is accurate though. . your making 1/10 the money you used to . . cause yt is not as profitable as it used to be. You need to post 10x's more than you used to and YT is a lot better now so you post 1/2 . . money drops. Simple as that.

I think your using webbrowser.
I am using a comment poster I created, so each thread has its own cookies.
I made a bitly link creator to make thousands of bitly links in a flash, so each comment have different links.
And I post comment once per account at a time.
Its getting thru

Also forgot to mention I make many variable strings like (Im, I, I am) and my software gets 1 word from that nested strings.

You know, there is one common denominator in all other sections, where it used to be easy to post into one application (myspace, youtube, craigslist), but no longer. I dare not mention it here, because as I've been an avid searcher on this forum, I strongly deduce that it was a result of an idea that was mentioned on how CL could hinder BH'ers - and soon after did in fact go into affect. It's so simple that I assumed others were aware of it. But I see now; not all. There has to be CL spys on here, so if I get PM'd, I will only mention it to certain posters.

__________________
HE'S LIKE THE FONZ. ONLY A DOG. HOW F'ING COOL IS THAT?

my God man a 2009 escalade, and your only just of a legal age. jesus..

Yea but YouTube is not my only way of making money I have many WH and BH methods that I use. Anyways..

I do use a comment poster as stated in the first thread , I hired a freelancer to make me one. It doesn't use a browser.